Brazilian vs European Portuguese: what actually differs
Brazilian and European Portuguese are one language with one written standard, and a Brazilian and a Lisbon newspaper can be read by the same person without trouble. Spoken, they are much further apart, and a learner who started with one is often surprised by the other. This post goes through the differences in the order a learner meets them — sound, the word for "you", grammar, everyday words and spelling — and measures the ones that can be measured, in film and television dialogue from each country.
The sound: the biggest difference
Vowels. Portuguese reduces the vowels of unstressed syllables, and European Portuguese does it far more. In Portugal an unstressed e is often a very short, barely voiced sound or disappears altogether, so a word can lose a whole syllable in speech. Brazilian Portuguese pronounces its vowels more openly, even when they are reduced. It is why European Portuguese can sound fast and full of consonants to a newcomer, and Brazilian Portuguese more open.
Final vowels. After the stressed syllable, Brazilians usually say an unstressed e as "ee" and o as "oo": leite (milk) ends in "-chee", tudo (everything) in "-doo".
T and d before an "ee" sound. In most of Brazil, t and d before that sound become something close to English "ch" and "j": tia (aunt) sounds like "chee-a", dia (day) like "jee-a", and leite like "lay-chee". European Portuguese keeps a plain t and d.
If you learn one variety, these are the things that will make the other sound foreign. None of them changes a word's spelling, and none of them can be seen in a frequency list.
"You": você and tu
The most visible difference in grammar is the word for "you".
- In Brazil, você is the everyday "you" for almost everyone, and it takes the same verb form as "he" and "she": você fala, "you speak". Tu survives in some regions, often with that same verb form (tu fala), but many Brazilians never use it.
- In Portugal, tu is the normal familiar "you", with its own verb form: tu falas, tu estás. Você exists, but using it to someone's face can sound distant or awkward, and polite speech often uses a title instead: o senhor, a senhora.
The subtitle lists show how deep this goes. Você is word number 7 in Brazilian dialogue and 59 in European; tu is 54 in Portugal and 972 in Brazil. The plural "you" is vocês in both (rank 93 in Brazil, 160 in Portugal), while the old plural vós is still more alive in Portugal (rank 1,222) than in Brazil (5,590).
Brazilians also say a gente ("people") for "we", with a "he/she" verb: a gente vai, "we're going". Nós vamos is equally correct and still common.
Grammar: two measurable differences
"I am doing." Brazil forms the progressive with the gerund, estou fazendo; Portugal mostly with a and the infinitive, estou a fazer. So the gerund forms are everyday words in Brazil and uncommon in Portugal:
| Word | Meaning | Rank in Brazil | Rank in Portugal |
|---|---|---|---|
| fazendo | doing | 150 | 1,011 |
| indo | going | 253 | 1,763 |
| falando | speaking | 215 | 1,477 |
| tentando | trying | 297 | 2,135 |
Fazendo is said about 877 times per million words in Brazil and 87 in Portugal: roughly ten times as often.
Where the pronoun goes. Brazilians put object pronouns before the verb, me dá ("give me"); in Portugal they usually follow it, joined by a hyphen, dá-me. The hyphenated forms are among the thousand commonest words in European dialogue — deixa-me ("let me") at rank 411, dá-me at 513, diz-me ("tell me") at 583 — and none of the three appears in the Brazilian list at all.
Everyday words
Some common words are simply different. Each is common in one country and rare in the other:
| Meaning | Brazil | Rank there | Portugal | Rank there |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| boy, kid | garoto | 381 | miúdo | 655 |
| bathroom | banheiro | 903 | casa de banho | — |
| breakfast | café da manhã | — | pequeno-almoço | 2,057 |
| fridge | geladeira | 3,804 | frigorífico | 4,081 |
| juice | suco | 3,192 | sumo | 3,245 |
| cup | xícara | 4,025 | chávena | 5,749 |
| screen | tela | 3,098 | ecrã | 5,136 |
Multi-word expressions have no single rank, which is why two cells are empty. The famous pairs — ônibus and autocarro for "bus", trem and comboio for "train", celular and telemóvel for "phone" — are measured in how many words you need to speak Portuguese.
One word deserves a warning of its own. In Portugal rapariga is simply "girl" (rank 426 in European dialogue); in parts of Brazil it is an insult, with Priberam's dictionary giving "prostitute" as a Brazilian regional sense. Brazilians say menina or moça.
Spelling: nearly unified
Until the Orthographic Agreement of 1990, Portugal kept many consonants that were no longer pronounced — acção, óptimo — while Brazil had dropped them: ação, ótimo. The agreement removed the silent consonants from European spelling too, so the written standards are now almost identical. The subtitle lists still show the old habit: óptimo is rank 330 in the European list against 989 for ótimo, because much of what was subtitled predates the change.
Where a consonant is still pronounced in one country and not the other, the spellings still differ. Portugal says and writes facto ("fact"); Brazil writes fato. In Portugal fato is a different word: a suit.
Which should you learn?
- Choose one variety for speaking. The shared core is most of any text, but mixing você and tu, or fazendo and a fazer, sounds odd in both countries.
- Brazilian Portuguese is the variety a learner is most likely to hear: Brazil is by far the largest Portuguese-speaking country. Its more open vowels also tend to be easier for a beginner to catch.
- European Portuguese is the right choice if Portugal is your destination. Expect the listening to take longer, because of the reduced vowels.
Verbavia teaches Brazilian Portuguese: our Portuguese list and the Portuguese course follow Brazilian usage, with você, and its recordings are Brazilian voices. Is Portuguese hard to learn covers the sounds from an English speaker's side, and Portuguese vs Spanish measures how much a Spanish speaker already knows.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Brazilian Portuguese — vowel reduction and unstressed vowels, the palatalisation of t and d, você and tu, a gente, estar + gerund against estar a + infinitive, the position of object pronouns, and the silent consonants removed by the 1990 agreement (acção, óptimo; facto and fato).
- Priberam, Dicionário da Língua Portuguesa: rapariga — the Brazilian regional sense; fato — "suit" in Portugal; facto — spelt fato in Brazil.
- Lison, P. & Tiedemann, J. (2016). OpenSubtitles2016: Extracting Large Parallel Corpora from Movie and TV Subtitles. Proceedings of LREC 2016. aclanthology.org
- Dave, H. FrequencyWords: frequency lists from OpenSubtitles 2018, with separate Brazilian and European Portuguese lists, content licensed CC BY-SA 4.0. github.com. Every rank is computed by
scripts/frequency_curves.pyand printed from its output rather than typed.